Editorial: What a difference five years makes for Dustin Poirier and Charles Oliveira

Let’s rewind a bit. In fact, let’s go all the way back to 2016. On November 12th, a little less than three months after…

By: Mookie Alexander | 2 years ago
Editorial: What a difference five years makes for Dustin Poirier and Charles Oliveira
Bloody Elbow 2.0 | Anton Tabuena

Let’s rewind a bit.

In fact, let’s go all the way back to 2016.

On November 12th, a little less than three months after he avenged his upset loss to Nate Diaz in thrilling fashion, Conor McGregor made history as the first ever simultaneous two-division UFC champion when he emphatically dethroned Eddie Alvarez at UFC 205. It was the promotion’s maiden show at Madison Square Garden after New York finally legalized MMA. ‘Mystic Mac’ envisioned holding two UFC belts and knocked two legends out to turn that vision into reality.

One week prior to McGregor’s win over Alvarez, Charles Oliveira not only tapped to a second straight guillotine choke, he comically weighed in at 155 lbs for his featherweight matchup with Ricardo Lamas. It was his third loss in four fights, the fourth time he’d missed weight, and the last time the UFC has booked him at 145 lbs.

Meanwhile, almost exactly two years removed from his TKO defeat to McGregor, Dustin Poirier had entered his September main event vs. Michael Johnson on an impressive four-fight winning streak over Diego Ferreira, Yancy Medeiros, Joseph Duffy, and Bobby Green. Poirier was favored over Johnson, who had lost two straight (and also inadvertently sprung the McGregor vs. Diaz rivalry to life by losing to Nate), yet it was Johnson who pulled off the shocking 95-second KO of the ‘Diamond’ in Texas to abruptly halt Poirier’s rise up the lightweight ranks.

McGregor was on top of the MMA world both as a fighter and commercial superstar, Oliveira had to hit the reset button and leave featherweight, and Poirier closed out 2016 with a four spot tumble to #10 in the UFC’s official lightweight rankings.

Okay, now let’s fast forward to present day.

Oliveira and Poirier are a combined 18-2 (1 NC) over the past four years and are on a collision course to fight for the undisputed title in just a matter of months. McGregor made a ridiculous amount of money boxing Floyd Mayweather, but in terms of actual combat success, his lone win during that time span is a TKO of a demonstrably faded version of Donald Cerrone. He defended neither of his two belts and when he tried to win back the lightweight crown, Khabib Nurmagomedov choked him out—and then all hell broke loose.

While McGregor spent his post-Alvarez years loudly proclaiming, official slapping and referee confronting, bus window smashing, phone stomping, bar punching, fake retiring, and fake retiring again*, Poirier and Oliveira were separately – but relentlessly – working their way towards the zenith of one of the deepest divisions in MMA.

(*Not to leave out the two sexual assault accusations made against him, as well.)

Poirier established himself as top-shelf lightweight with his main event stoppages of Anthony Pettis, Justin Gaethje, and (in a rematch of their ‘no contest’ first fight) Eddie Alvarez. The suspension of Khabib for his UFC 229 post-fight brawl prompted an interim title Poirier would contest against then-featherweight king Max Holloway in 2019. What transpired was an all-time classic between two seemingly indefatigable athletes, with Poirier becoming the man to end Max’s 13-fight winning streak. That win netted the ATT talent a crack at true UFC gold, upon Khabib’s return from suspension—but for absolutely zero want of a better word, he got Khabib’d just like everyone else.

It was a considerably different story for Oliveira. The Brazilian choked out Will Brooks before getting elbowed to smithereens by Paul Felder, then rattled off six consecutive victories, all via stoppage. Unfortunately those wins came entirely over unranked opposition, including a pointless trilogy meeting with Nik Lentz. Which meant ‘Do Bronx’ ended 2019 ranked a modest #13 at 155 lbs. Not exactly in the immediate running for a shot at the belt.

Oliveira finally broke through as a legitimate title threat by submitting Kevin Lee just before the UFC’s schedule was put on ice due to the coronavirus pandemic. He then capped off his year by turning Tony Ferguson into his personal grappling dummy, solidifying his position as a top contender in the process.

We saw Poirier just once in 2020, rallying from a 2-0 deficit versus Dan Hooker to win a grueling five-round decision. A few weeks later, he outlined his intentions for the rest of his career.

“I’m not sure what the options will be when the UFC comes back and starts sitting at the table to make these matches,” Poirier said. “It needs to be a really big name or a title fight. I’ve been doing this for 10 years in the UFC, and I still love fighting, but I want these fights to mean more than just a fight. I don’t want it to just be about a show and win purse. I want it to really mean something, and I know I’m in the back nine of my career.”

Photo by Chris Unger/Zuffa LLC

Mission accomplished? Well he’s pretty damn close. Two big money fights and two wins over Conor McGregor. He eschewed the title shot for another hefty payday, effectively betting on himself that he would win and still compete for the championship.

Was last weekend’s fight an unfortunate ending? Yes. But, Poirier also clearly won the round. And if history is a guide, then McGregor was in for more punishment and head trauma if not for the leg break.

One of the most dangerous opening round fighters the sport has ever seen experienced the singular worst round one of his career, and only the most fervent McGregor defenders (his coaches included) could convince themselves Conor was positioned for better things to come.

Photo by Carmen Mandato/Getty Images

Sandwiched in between Poirier’s double over McGregor was Oliveira’s landmark moment. For a man who had developed a reputation for folding whenever he was met with serious resistance, it took a dramatic and rapid comeback KO for Oliveira to stop Michael Chandler and become the first UFC lightweight champ of the post-Khabib era. It took 28 UFC fights for the Chute Box talent to win a title, more than anyone else in the promotion’s history. His raw emotion and wild celebrations should be etched into the memories of anyone who watched him that night.

Through this five-year journey, Poirier and Oliveira have persevered, prospered, improved and sharpened their respective skill sets to become an unlikely – and yet fully deserving – pairing of championship competitors. We know where they stand as elites because they had to keep fighting to earn that respect. If the Khabib vs. McGregor rivalry had a level of genuine animosity and ugliness to it that may not be everyone’s cup of tea, Poirier and Oliveira are a breath of fresh air as golden representatives of what makes this sport great when you strip away the circus surrounding it.

On the flip side, McGregor may not yet be experiencing a financial downfall as a pay-per-view draw, but everything else continues to dip precipitously. We’ve already been through his boorish behavior, but his trash talk and general command of the microphone has devolved into a stream of mean-spirited threats and juvenile insults. He’s become something of a caricature of his former self.

The ‘Mystic Mac’ aura is dissipating and his retelling of his losses are more consistently divorced from reality than ever. None of his act, contrived or not, works as well when the wins aren’t being posted on the board. And yes, his inactivity has been an issue. He has fought two lightweights a combined three times in four years and lost them all. His broken leg will all but guarantee he’s not back until 2022. At this point, would anyone bet on Conor ever fighting more than one name on a list like Justin Gaethje, Michael Chandler, Dan Hooker, Beneil Dariush, or Rafael dos Anjos? I wouldn’t.

It’s hard enough already to predict this sport in the short term. I’d like to see the work of any fan or pundit that envisioned a Charles Oliveira vs. Dustin Poirier title bout even two years ago, let alone five. I can’t wait to see how it unfolds, and the only bad thing out of this is that they both can’t walk away with the UFC belt around their waist.

Share this story

About the author
Mookie Alexander
Mookie Alexander

Mookie is a former Associate Editor for Bloody Elbow, leaving in August 2022 after ten years as a member of the staff. He's still lurking behind the scenes.

More from the author

Bloody Elbow Podcast
Related Stories